Bright Hub Education

Bright Hub Education

  • Teaching Tools
    • Teaching Tools
    • Classroom Management
    • Education Industry
    • Student Assessment Tools
    • Teaching Methods
  • Preschool and Early Ed
    • Preschool and Early Ed
    • Infant Development
    • Parenting Tips and Advice
    • Preschool Crafts and Activities
    • Preschool Lesson Plans and Theme
    • Preschool Teaching Strategies
    • Toddler Activities and Ideas
  • Elementary School
    • Elementary School
    • Grade School Activities
    • Lesson Plans for Pre-K and K
    • Lesson Plans: Grades 1 - 2
    • Lesson Plans: Grades 3 - 5
    • Parenting Grade Schoolers
    • Teaching Younger Students
  • Middle School
    • Middle School
    • English Lessons: Grades 6-8
    • History Lessons: Grades 6-8
    • Math Lessons: Grades 6-8
    • Parenting Preteens and Tweens
    • Science Lessons: Grades 6-8
    • Social Studies: Grades 6-8
    • Teaching Middle Schoolers
    • The Arts: Grades 6-8
  • More
    • High School(7)
    • Homework Help(20)
    • Special Ed(11)
    • More Areas(4)
More
High School (7)
Homework Help (20)
Special Ed (11)
More Areas (4)
English Lessons: Grades 9-12
High School Teaching Tips
History Lessons: Grades 9-12
Math Lessons: Grades 9-12
Parenting Teens
Science Lessons: Grades 9-12
The Arts: Grades 9-12
English Help
Geography Facts
Help with German
Help with Latin
Help with Writing
History Help
Language Learning Strategies
Learning Chinese
Learning French
Learning Italian
Learning Japanese
Learning Spanish
Literature Study Guides
Math Facts
Miscellaneous Languages
Science Homework Help
Science Projects
Social Studies Help
Study and Learning Tips
Test Preparation
Behavioral Disorders
Gifted and Exceptional St...
Hearing Impairments
IDEA, IEPs and The Law
Inclusion Strategies
Learning Disorders
Neurological Disorders
Physical Disabilities
Special Ed: Parent Perspe...
Speech Disorders
Visual Impairments
Homeschooling Advice
Summer Learning
Teaching a Second Language
Teaching ESL Learners
    Skip to content
    768

    The Financial Makeup of Charter Schools: Are They Hurting or Helping Public Education?

    Education Industry News & Opinion / By Mary Beth Adomaitis / Teaching Methods, Tools & Strategies

    School Building Pin it! Share on Facebook

    Since the Charter School Movement began 20 years ago, school districts across the country have questioned the effects they have on public school budgets. Are taxpayers getting their money’s worth with charter schools? While the data coming from these schools are hard to measure, it does show that not all charter schools are producing higher achieving students.

    Opponents argue that charter schools are draining public school budgets and spending money that is needed elsewhere in the district. Proponents disagree, stating that the cost to educate children at either type of school is the same. The best way to determine if charter schools negatively impact a public school’s budget is to take a closer look at how typical charter school are funded.

    How Charter Schools are Financed

    Charter schools are the fast-growing educational reform movement to date. Forty states and the District of Columbia have charter school laws on the books that offer students a chance at a wider range of elementary and secondary school choices. However, financing charter schools varies from state to state, as well as from the standard public school protocol.

    Because charter schools are public schools, they receive local and state funding. They both depend on their average daily attendance (ADA) to determine how much they will receive. These public monies follow the student no matter what public school — charter or traditional — he or she attends. Some states require that charter schools negotiate their funding with the local school district, while others receive only a fraction of the money that is typically allocated to public school students. It all depends on how each state’s charter is written.

    Because this is typically all the public funding charter schools receive, educators have to rely on private loans and donations from outside sources to fill in the financial gaps. In some instances, charter schools can receive federal or state grant money if it is available. Most charter schools can also receive services and funding for Special Education students, depending on how it’s outlined in its charter.1

    One major difference between traditional public schools and charter schools’ funding is that the latter does not receive start-up money to cover the cost of the buildings and other start-up expenses, unless it is specifically outlined in its state charter. However, the remainder of the operating costs, including salaries, rent, utilities, books, insurance and supplies, is picked up by private donations, endowments, or loans.

    When Charter Schools Financially Hurt Public Schools

    Just because the public funds follow a student from public to charter school doesn’t mean it isn’t always felt in the former’s budget. For example, a Maine public school district superintendent said local charter schools are expenses that weren’t originally planned for in his budget this year.

    So far in 2012, the district has lost a half-million dollars because the cost of educating a child in a charter school is more than what the state allocates. Therefore, the public school district has to make up the difference, though the child doesn’t attend the traditional school. Another hit to this public school district’s budget is that although 42 out of the district’s 2,800 students now attend charter schools, that wasn’t enough of a student reduction to eliminate staff positions or busing.2 This school district is spending the same amount of money to educate a smaller student body with less funds.

    Opponents feel that even the smallest number of students leaving a traditional school for a charter school can impact the stability of a school’s finances especially if enrollment numbers are put together right before the school year begins, which typically is after a school budget is approved.

    Is a Change Needed?

    For charter schools to be successful, they have to be financially sound as well as educationally competitive. If state or local public monies aren’t enough to support these alternative schools, then new ways need to be found. A top-notch charter school is only as good as the finances supporting it. Once the money runs out, there’s a good chance the school will close.

    References

    • 2: “Public School District Budgets Take Cash Hit for Charter School Tuition” http://www.kjonline.com/news/other-districts-brace-for-budget-hits_2012-11-25.html
    • Photo by derrypubliclibrary under CC BY 2.0 via Flickr
    • 1: “Charter School Funding” http://www.edsource.org/iss_fin_sys_charters.html

    Post navigation

    ← Previous Post
    Next Post →
    Copyright © 2019 Bright Hub Education. All Rights Reserved.
    About | Copyright Policy | Privacy Policy | Terms of Use

    Search



    More Info

    Recent

    • What Are the Functions of a Teachers’ Union?
    • Are Online Schools the Future of Education?
    • How to Afford to Live in the School District You Teach For
    • 3 Emerging Education Technologies for 2015-2016
    • The US Education System Is Still Good, It Just Needs a Boost
    • UK vs. USA: Who Has the Better Education System?


    Popular Pages

    • Home
    • Privacy Policy

    © brighthubeducation.com. All rights reserved.